Foucault s Monsters and the Challenge of Law

But, although Foucault’s theoretical framework for understanding the monster is affirmed here, this book's study of an English legal history of the category ‘monster’ challenges some of Foucault’s historical claims.

Foucault s Monsters and the Challenge of Law

Author: Alex Sharpe

Publisher: Routledge

ISBN: 1135182655

Page: 184

View: 381

In contrast to other figures generated within social theory for thinking about outsiders, such as Rene Girard’s ‘scapegoat’ and Zygmunt Bauman’s ‘stranger’, Foucault’s Monsters and the Challenge of Law suggests that the figure of ‘the monster’ offers greater analytical precision and explanatory power in relation to understanding the processes whereby outsiders are constituted. The book draws on Michel Foucault’s theoretical and historical treatment of the category of the monster, in which the monster is regarded as the effect of a double breach: of law and nature. For Foucault, the monster does not simply refer to a particular kind of morphological or psychological irregularity; for the body or psyche in question must also pose a threat to the categorical structure of law. In chronological terms, Foucault moves from a preoccupation with the bestial human in the Middle Ages to a concern over Siamese or conjoined twins in the Renaissance period, and ultimately to a focus on the hermaphrodite in the Classical Age. But, although Foucault’s theoretical framework for understanding the monster is affirmed here, this book's study of an English legal history of the category ‘monster’ challenges some of Foucault’s historical claims. In addition to considering this legal history, the book also addresses the contemporary relevance of Foucault’s theoretical framework. Structured around Foucault’s archetypes and the category crises they represent – admixed embryos, conjoined twins and transsexuals – the book analyses their challenge to current distinctions between human and animal, male and female, and the idea of the ‘proper’ legal subject as a single embodied mind. These contemporary figures, like the monsters of old, are shown to threaten the rigidity and binary structure of a law that still struggles to accommodate them.

Related Books:

Foucault's Monsters and the Challenge of Law
Language: en
Pages: 184
Authors: Alex Sharpe
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2009-12-16 - Publisher: Routledge

In contrast to other figures generated within social theory for thinking about outsiders, such as Rene Girard’s ‘scapegoat’ and Zygmunt Bauman’s ‘stranger’, Foucault’s Monsters and the Challenge of Law suggests that the figure of ‘the monster’ offers greater analytical precision and explanatory power in relation to understanding the processes whereby
Foucault and Law
Language: en
Pages: 566
Authors: Peter Fitzpatrick
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2017-07-05 - Publisher: Routledge

Few thinkers can have had a more diverse or a more contested impact on theorizing law than Michel Foucault. This diversity is reflected in the wide range of Foucault's work and of the intellectual fields it has so conspicuously influenced. Such diversity informs the present collection and is signalled in
Law and Gender in Modern Ireland
Language: en
Pages: 304
Authors: Lynsey Black, Peter Dunne
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2019-02-21 - Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing

Law and Gender in Modern Ireland: Critique and Reform is the first generalist text to tackle the intersection of law and gender in this jurisdiction for over two decades. As such, it could hardly have come at a more opportune moment. The topic of law and gender, perhaps more so
Inspiring a Medico-Legal Revolution
Language: en
Pages: 324
Authors: Pamela R. Ferguson, Graeme T. Laurie
Categories: Medical
Type: BOOK - Published: 2016-03-09 - Publisher: Routledge

This book marks the retirement of Professor Sheila McLean, whose contribution to the discipline of medical law has been truly ground breaking. As one of the pioneers of the discipline, Sheila McLean inspired a revolution in the ways in which lawyers, doctors, courts and patients perceive the relationship between medicine
Monsters and Monstrosity
Language: en
Pages: 307
Authors: Daniela Carpi
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2019-06-17 - Publisher: Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co KG

Every culture knows the phenomenon of monsters, terrifying creatures that represent complete alterity and challenge every basic notion of self and identity within a cultural paradigm. In Latin and Greek culture, the monster was created as a marvel, appearing as something which, like transgression itself, did not belong to the