Lazy Improvident People

... Writing of Spanish History Ruth MacKay. “Lazy, Improvident People” “Lazy, Improvident People” Myth and Reality in the Writing of "Lazy, Improvident People"

 Lazy  Improvident People

Author: Ruth MacKay

Publisher: Cornell University Press

ISBN: 1501728385

Page: 312

View: 205

Since the early modern era, historians and observers of Spain, both within the country and beyond it, have identified a peculiarly Spanish disdain for work, especially manual labor, and have seen it as a primary explanation for that nation's alleged failure to develop like the rest of Europe. In "Lazy, Improvident People" the historian Ruth MacKay examines the origins of this deeply ingrained historical prejudice and cultural stereotype. MacKay finds these origins in the ilustrados, the Enlightenment intellectuals and reformers who rose to prominence in the late eighteenth century. To advance their own, patriotic project of rationalization and progress, they disparaged what had gone before. Relying in part on late medieval and early modern political treatises about "vile and mechanical" labor, they claimed that previous generations of Spaniards had been indolent and backward. Through a close reading of the archival record, MacKay shows that such treatises and dramatic literature in no way reflected the actual lives of early modern artisans, who were neither particularly slothful nor untalented. On the contrary, they behaved as citizens, and their work was seen as dignified and essential to the common good. MacKay contends that the ilustrados' profound misreading of their own past created a propagandistic myth that has been internalized by subsequent intellectuals. MacKay's is thus a book about the notion of Spanish exceptionalism, the ways in which this notion developed, and the burden and skewed vision it has imposed on Spaniards and outsiders. "Lazy, Improvident People" will fascinate not only historians of early modern and modern Spain but all readers who are concerned with the process by which historical narratives are formed, reproduced, and given authority.

Related Books:

Language: en
Pages: 312
Authors: Ruth MacKay
Categories: History
Type: BOOK - Published: 2018-07-05 - Publisher: Cornell University Press

Since the early modern era, historians and observers of Spain, both within the country and beyond it, have identified a peculiarly Spanish disdain for work, especially manual labor, and have seen it as a primary explanation for that nation's alleged failure to develop like the rest of Europe. In "Lazy,
Gendered Crossings
Language: en
Pages: 296
Authors: Allyson M. Poska
Categories: History
Type: BOOK - Published: 2016-02-15 - Publisher: UNM Press

Between 1778 and 1784 the Spanish Crown transported more than 1,900 peasants, including 875 women and girls, from northern Spain to South America in an ill-fated scheme to colonize Patagonia. The story begins as the colonists trudge across northern Spain to volunteer for the project and follows them across the
A Trip to Spain, or a true description of the comical humours, ridiculous customs and foolish laws of that lazy improvident people the Spaniards. In a letter to a person of quality, from an Officer of the Royal Navy
Language: en
Pages:
Authors: Spain
Categories: History
Type: BOOK - Published: 1704 - Publisher:

Books about A Trip to Spain, or a true description of the comical humours, ridiculous customs and foolish laws of that lazy improvident people the Spaniards. In a letter to a person of quality, from an Officer of the Royal Navy
Lexikon of the Hispanic Baroque
Language: en
Pages: 352
Authors: Evonne Levy, Kenneth Mills
Categories: Art
Type: BOOK - Published: 2014-01-06 - Publisher: University of Texas Press

Over the course of some two centuries following the conquests and consolidations of Spanish rule in the Americas during the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries—the period designated as the Baroque—new cultural forms sprang from the cross-fertilization of Spanish, Amerindian, and African traditions. This dynamism of motion, relocation, and mutation
Honor and Personhood in Early Modern Mexico
Language: en
Pages: 237
Authors: Osvaldo F. Pardo
Categories: History
Type: BOOK - Published: 2015-09-24 - Publisher: University of Michigan Press

An examination of the concept of honor as essential to both colonial Spaniards and indigenous Mexicans